Contentious Probate in the Spotlight: Lessons from the Liam Payne Estate

Following Liam Payne’s tragic passing at only 31 years old, it has recently been reported that he has left behind a £24.3 million fortune—without a will. This high-profile case offers a sobering example of t

he challenges that can arise when someone dies intestate.

Cheryl Tweedy, his former partner and the mother of his son Bear, has been appointed as an administrator of the estate alongside a music industry lawyer. Under intestacy rules in England and Wales, Bear is the primary beneficiary, and as he is a minor, his mother is entitled to extract the letters of administration on his behalf.

Why does this matter from a contentious probate perspective?

• Disputes are common: High-value estates and blended families often lead to disagreements over who should benefit and how assets are managed.

• Co-administrator challenges: With both Cheryl and a professional administrator involved, there’s potential for differing views on estate management, which can cause delays or legal disputes.

• Potential claims: Others who feel inadequately provided for may bring claims under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 ("the Act"), adding further complexity. Notably, Payne’s girlfriend, Kate Cassidy, despite their two-year relationship, will receive nothing under intestacy rules. However, if she can prove cohabitation or financial dependence, she may have a claim under the Act, potentially resulting in litigation against both the administrator and Bear as beneficiary.

• Emotional and financial strain: Contentious probate matters can prolong the grieving process and increase legal costs, particularly when the estate is substantial and public interest is high.

As a solicitor specialising in contentious probate, wills, and trusts, I regularly advise individuals facing these challenges—whether it’s disputes over estate administration, claims of professional negligence, or disagreements between beneficiaries and executors.

What can be done to avoid contentious probate?

• Make a clear, legally binding will, especially if you have significant assets or complex family circumstances.

• Consider trusts to protect vulnerable beneficiaries.

• Seek legal advice early—prevention is far less costly, emotionally and financially, than resolving disputes after the fact.

At Middleton Legal & Business Services, we help clients navigate contentious probate and resolve disputes efficiently and sensitively. If you’re managing a difficult estate or want to safeguard your family’s future, we're here to support you with practical, tailored advice.